At my December book club, we held a book exchange. Everyone brought a wrapped book with a note on the front telling why the reader enjoyed the book without giving away the author or title. We had fun choosing and stealing from one another; we put a limit of three steals on a book. The book I stole from another member was The Echo of Old Books by Barbara Davis. Fortunately, I managed to hold on to it! And am I glad!
We readers are familiar with the alternating story format wherein a story is told in two periods of time or by two or three narrators. Davis has employed yet another technique. Davis gives readers Belle’s story in her own hand along with Hemi’s story in his words. The two were lovers in the 1940s, but a terrible misunderstanding tore them apart. Along with Belle’s and Hemi’s stories, readers also discover Ashlyn’s story which takes place in 1984 and 1985. What connects these three stories? That’s what readers will discover, much to their delight.
Ashlyn, owner of a rare bookstore, discovers companion books, a woman’s story and a man’s story, in a thrift shop. The books obviously belong together, but they have no authors’ names, no publisher’s name, and no imprint date. Ashlyn feels compelled to read the two stories, and she does so by reading part of Hemi’s story followed by part of Belle’s story.
I must also mention that Ashlyn has a rare gift regarding books. When she touches certain books, Ashlyn gets a strong feeling of joy, sorrow, or revulsion. She soon learns the gift has a name: psychometry. Merriam-Webster defines psychometry this way: “divination of facts concerning an object or its owner through contact with or proximity to the object.” Ashlyn’s mother tells her to keep that secret to herself. Eventually, Ashlyn reveals her special gift to Frank who owns the bookstore where Ashlyn finds solace and later owns. Frank tells her, “Books are like people, Ashlyn. They absorb what’s in the air around them. Smoke. Grease. Mold spores. Why not feelings? There’s nothing more personal than a book, especially one that’s become an important part of someone’s life?”
Frank’s next response is even more telling: “Books are feelings. They exist to make us feel. To connect us to what’s inside, sometimes to things we don’t even know are there.”
Determined to ferret out the real names of the people who wrote the stories, Ashlyn begins sleuthing. Through the thrift shop owner, Ashlyn finds out the name of the person who brought the books into the store: Ethan Manning. She contacts Ethan to see what he knows about the books; their first meetings are fraught with frustration on her part because Ethan appears to have no interest in the books or his own family history.
Through her persistence, Ashlyn makes a little headway with Ethan regarding the books, enough that he starts reading them too. He realizes Belle’s story is that of his great-aunt Marian whom he met only a few times when he was a boy. With this knowledge, Ashlyn and Ethan embark on further investigations into the two stories.
Readers will have to read The Echo of Old Books to discover what happens. Some readers may guess the ending (or I might say endings plural!), but there will be surprises, nonetheless. Book club members will enjoy discussing the backstory of the two lovers in the 1940s as well as the mystery of the two books. The way Ashlyn and Ethan discover the truth about Belle and Hemi will also be a topic of discussion. Happy reading!